PALO ALTO COLLEGE
SAN ANTONIO, TEXAS
Cotton Mather, Puritan Minister Theme Four:
Religion and Gender Roles
in Colonial America
Salem Witch Trials
Robert R. Hines
Assistant Professor of History



Theme #4: Religion in Colonial America

Assigned Readings:

Flyover History Text, Chapter 10
Courtship in Early America

The Salem Witch Trials
Quakers

Internet Required: (A) (B) (C) (D) (E).

Instructor's Introduction: My goal with this theme is to introduce students to a world completely different from our own: New England of the late seventeenth and early eighteenth centuries. For these people, religion was not just something you did on Sundays. Oh, no. It was the central focus of their lives. Before entering this world, let us try to leave our own ideas about religion, science, and gender equality behind. For they simply do not apply here. Introduce yourself to the variety of religious experience of the seventeenth century. The Library of Congress site details persecutions, bibles, and religous leaders of the time. Then you should be ready for the more challenging exercises that follow. Good luck, and keep an open mind...

 

 

(A) Read Chapter 10 of the Flyover History Text, Bearing the Burden? Puritan Wives, by Martha Saxton. Answer the following questions in one, well-organized essay:
1. How did Puritans define gender roles?
2. How might Puritan beliefs have played a role in defining the role of men and women?
3. Which stories in the article helped you to understand the status of women in Puritan life?
4. What were some of the ironies faced by women in this world? In what ways did their beliefs appear to be inconsistent (at least by our modern standards)?
5. What did such men as Cotton Mather believe to be the qualities of the best women in their community?

 

(B) Go to Courtship in Early America
Summarize Puritan beliefs about courtship and marriage. How did they view "romantic love"? Why? How did things change by the mid-eighteenth century? What is the evidence for this? What was primogeniture? What happened to this practice, and why? What was the practice of "bundling"? (I wonder how well this worked...hmmm.) How did marriage customs change over time? What was the
legal status
of a woman in Massachusetts Bay Colony? Finally, how does the story of Abigail Abbott Bailey illustrate the woman's dilemna at that time? How do you react to this story?

 

Salem Witch Trials

 


(C) Salem Witch Trials

Famous American Trials: The Salem Witch Trials, 1692.  This site contains good introductory information on the Salem Witch trials. Use this as the basis for these essays:

Part 1: Review the main links in brief essays.  Then explore the rest of the site, and write a critical essay about it. What is good, what could be better. What questions come to mind that you feel were left out of this site? What questions about this period would you want to know more about?.

Part 2: In a short essay, answer these questions, using these sites or other websites: What do the Salem Witch Trials represent in the broader history of religion in this country? What do the trials tell us about the notions of village life and colonial values? What do they tell us about the role(s) of women in colonial New England? These are meant to be open-ended questions, so the facts, plus your opinions, are relevant in answering them.

Brief review of Carol Karlsen's The Devil in the Shape of a Woman, an historical account of the Witch Trials. (This is NOT required!)

 

George Fox, Founder of the Quakers (The Society of Friends)

 

(D) The Quakers (Society of Friends): Few religions in American history have done more to effect changes in our society than this small, fervent group of radical protestant Christians. What were the core beliefs of the Quakers? Why did they feel ministers/priests were unimportant? Who wrote the Bible, according to the Quakers, and why did they feel this way? What were (are) their beliefs about men/women, and racial differences amongst us?

 

 

(E) Read the brief story of John Newton, author of the folk hymn Amazing Grace.
Questions: What is the connection between the song and the man who wrote it? What does the song mean, both for the generation in which it appeared, and our own? Why has this hymn stood the test of time?



Additional Resources: (Not Required!)
Film: The Crucible, with Winona Rider and Daniel Day Lewis.
The Salem Witch Trials, with a modern twist...

Salem Witch Trials
Good site for details on one of the most controversial events in North American history

The Quakers: Accurate Information
Good site for overview of Quaker (Society of Friends) history, beliefs, bibliography.

Back to the Main Menu

Online ACCD Library Catalog | Palo Alto Library | Palo Alto College